John's Pizzeria

Discover authentic NYC-style pizza at John's Pizzeria in Elmhurst, NY. Enjoy classic crust, delicious sausage rolls, nostalgic vibes, and unbeatable prices since 1965. Visit us at 85-02 Grand Ave or call +1 718-457-7561 today!

Welcome to John's Pizzeria

Signature Dining Experience

John's Pizzeria
John's Pizzeria
John's Pizzeria
John's Pizzeria

Step into John's Pizzeria, a cherished Elmhurst gem since 1965. Nestled at 85-02 Grand Ave, this spot radiates old-world charm with its classic formica tables and nostalgic décor. The moment you walk through the door, the rich aroma of freshly baked pizza and savory rolls envelops you, transporting you back to a simpler time. Customers rave about the perfectly baked crust, loaded toppings, and generous portions, all at wallet-friendly prices. Whether you're a local or just visiting, this pizzeria captures the heart and soul of New York City’s pizza culture. With a cozy vibe and warm service, it becomes more than just a meal; it’s a trip down memory lane.

Location & Contact

Address

85-02 Grand Ave, Elmhurst, NY 11373, United States

Phone

+1 718-457-7561

Social Media

About

John's Pizzeria
John's Pizzeria
John's Pizzeria
John's Pizzeria

Founded in 1965, John's Pizzeria stands as a testament to Elmhurst's culinary landscape. Its history is deeply woven into the community fabric, having built a loyal following of locals who have enjoyed its hearty offerings for decades. The pizzeria boasts 33 indulgent menu items, ensuring that every visitor finds something to savor. The pizzas are crafted with care, using the finest ingredients and traditional methods, which result in a crust that perfectly balances crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside.

In addition to the classic cheese and pepperoni pies, John's Pizzeria presents a variety of specialty pizzas.

The Meat Lovers Pizza satisfies those who crave a hearty feast, while the Veggie Pizza appeals to a lighter appetite. Customers can also indulge in hot heroes and baked rolls. Each dish pays homage to a timeless New York style that resonates with numerous patrons. The sausage roll and chicken cutlet hero, in particular, have earned rave reviews, embodying the true essence of comfort food.

What sets John's apart is not just the delicious food but the experience.

Patrons often reminisce about their first visit or recall fond memories spent here with family. The friendly staff creates an inviting atmosphere, making each customer feel like part of the family. With a commitment to quality and preservation of tradition, John's Pizzeria is more than just a dining spot; it’s a remarkable slice of Elmhurst's history. Whether it's a quick lunch break or a weekend feast, this pizzeria remains a cherished destination.

Work Hours

  • Sunday12-8 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday12-8 PM
  • Thursday12-8 PM
  • Friday12-8 PM
  • Saturday12-8 PM

John's Pizzeria offers an extensive menu brimming with delicious options. The pizza features a crispy crust, topped with a variety of ingredients, including classics like pepperoni and sausage, along with signature creations such as John's Special and Hawaiian Pizza. The pizzeria also excels in hot heroes and baked rolls, with choices like the beloved sausage roll and chicken cutlet hero.

The atmosphere is vibrant, drawing families, friends, and nostalgia-seekers alike.

Peaks of activity occur during peak dinner hours, especially on Wednesdays, when the restaurant reaches full capacity. For quieter moments, lunchtime on Saturdays offers the perfect opportunity to grab a slice without the wait. The community often gathers here, emphasizing the warmth and camaraderie synonymous with the neighborhood.

John's Pizzeria

The exterior of John's Pizzeria is as inviting as the flavorful dishes inside. With its classic signage and storefront, this pizzeria fits seamlessly in the bustling Elmhurst neighborhood. The vibrant energy of Grand Avenue reflects the busy life of the city while providing an atmosphere rich in welcoming charm.

Outdoor seating adds to the charm during warmer months, allowing guests to enjoy their food al fresco. The lively street atmosphere is enhanced by the sounds of conversations and laughter, creating an inviting space for both locals and visitors. This unique vibe makes each visit feel special, fostering connections between customers who share the love for great pizza.

Customer Reviews

The NYC Pizzeria has been a long declining institution, but John's seems to be doing all the right things. An excellent regular and Sicilian slice, fair prices, and an atmosphere straight out of the 1980's. Most modern pizza shops have become sterile in their makeovers, which are mostly an afterthought. John's keeps it old school with formica, wall paper, period correct seating, bar stools, and the quintessential red tile flooring. You don't just come here for the pizza, you come here for an experience. Put your phone away and just soak in the nostalgia as you enjoy a slice at John's. As a lifelong New Yorker since 1980, I approve this message.

T
Thanassi K.

Classic thin crust pizza, delicious sauce. I'm glad I discovered this place because this simple tasty style of pizza is hard to find. Topping choices are limited, so I only come here when I missing this classic style.

D
Daniel

First time I've had John's was around 1986. Last evening I went with my GF Eva after not going for approximately 10+ years. It definitely brought back so many memories and nostalgia from my childhood.

J
James O.

This wonderful gem has been here a long time. I've been getting pizza from here since 1993. I moved from Queens 8 years ago. I was in the neighborhood today and decided to stop in. It's as it was when I left. The pizza is just as good and the ladies who run it just as fantastic. You won't be disappointed.

R
Russell M.

First time going in here. We went around 430pm so it wasn't as crowded there we saw two beautiful elderly women working with so much passion and it just warmed my heart cause I knew this pizza was going to taste just as good! We ordered mushroom and pepperoni slice. We will definitely come many more times. Thank you

M
Mingmar L.

My all the time fav8 pizza place.. two angles work there .the pizza always fresh made.. the place is always clean.

J
Junni D.